Refusing to Provide a Breath Sample into an Approved Screening Device
RV T.H.H (May 2018)
The Issue
My client was charged with: Refusing to Provide a Breath Sample into an approved Screening Device. I successfully obtained a finding of not guilty after effectively cross-examining the only Crown witness, the arresting officer. I brought to light that the officer failed to fully explain how to provide a sample. And he failed to check the mouthpiece for any obstructions. As a result, the Judge found that my client was not guilty.
The Offence
Failing or refusing to provide a breath sample into an approved screening device pursuant to S.254(2) (b) of the Criminal Code of Canada, is an offence, whether you verbally refuse to provide a sample, or you fail to provide one by ineffectively blowing into the mouthpiece without a lawful excuse. Upon conviction, a person would face a criminal record. And upon a first conviction, with no extraordinary circumstances such as accident, personal injuries etc …, usually a fine and a period of driving prohibition occur.
Further to the foregoing consequences, a person in Ontario also faces, having to complete the On Track Program and the installation of an interlock device on their vehicle (a device where the driver must provide a sample of their alcohol-free breath at random times, for the vehicle to remain operative). A person’s vehicle insurance will also increase, sometimes to the point of being prohibitive.
The Right Lawyer to Defend Your Case
In this case, my client had initially retained other counsel, who, based on the disclosure provided, advised my client to plea guilty. While in certain cases, it is impossible to give a probability of winning or losing, in some, as in this case, my client had nothing to lose by going to trial and everything to gain. The resolution before trial would have been the same if she lost after trial. There were no incentives to plead guilty. A good Trial lawyer is able to make the distinction between a case that should go to Trial, and one that should not. If you want a good trial lawyer call Donna Pledge. A criminal defense lawyer that has been practicing for over twenty-six years.
Call 416-630-8702 or click here to email
Donna V. Pledge, Barrister & Solicitor
Donna V Pledge, is a highly experienced criminal lawyer in Toronto with over twenty-five years of experience in the area of criminal offences. She has been successfully defending clients since 1992. She has earned the reputation of a tough and no-nonsense lawyer who can get her clients out of any criminal case with either a full acquittal or a very light sentence. Donna Pledge represents her clients in courts all over Ontario.
