R v K.S.- Charged with Sexual Assault and Exposing Himself for a Sexual Purpose to a 15 Year Old Girl

Found Not Guilty

My client was charged with sexual assault and exposing himself for a sexual purpose to a 15-year-old girl and plead not guilty. The matter went to trial over a 4-day period. After hearing evidence from 3 witnesses for the crown and 2 witnesses for the defence, including my client, my client was found not guilty of both charges.

The Facts

My client was travelling to work one morning on the Subway. The subway car he was travelling on was very busy and it was standing room only. My client suffers from severe skin allergies that affect at times his whole body. On this day his allergies flared up in the area of his private parts. As a result, my client wore shorts and no underwear because his penis was swollen and inflamed. During the course of travelling on the subway car, my client was scratching his private parts over his clothes. A woman seated on the same subway car alleged that my client not only exposed his penis to a young school girl but also rubbed his erect penis on her skirt. As a result, upon exiting the subway car, my client was arrested.

The Trial

My client maintained his innocence throughout, and as a result the matter was scheduled for a trial. Ultimately there were 4 days of trial over a period of approximately 6 months. The matter from arrest to verdict took over 20 months. The stress and anxiety that my client experienced during this period was extreme. As well, his family, experienced tremendous amounts of stress and anxiety and financial pressures.

At trial the Judge found, as a result of my successful cross examination, among other facts, that the witness on the subway car, who alleged that my client not only exposed his penis but also rubbed his exposed erect penis on the young girl, was hyper-vigilant as a result of an incident that occurred years before when a naked man approached her. This may have led the witness to leap to a reasonable but inaccurate conclusion. Therefore, it may not have been unreasonable that the witness may have observed my client scratching his crotch and manipulating his shorts such that his penis was visible, but absent any sexual intent. Effective and excellent cross examination skills on my behalf led to my client being found not guilty.

Why Is It Important to Hire a Criminal Defence Lawyer?

Being charged with sexual assault and exposing oneself for a sexual purpose are very serious charges. Both of these charges carry a minimum jail sentence if the person is found guilty. Therefore, it is very important to hire a highly experienced criminal defence lawyer, in circumstances such as the foregoing example, to ensure a finding of not guilty.

If you have any questions about being charged with sexual assault and/or exposing oneself for a sexual purpose, please contact Donna Pledge today. She will ensure that you are represented to the fullest.

Call 416-630-8702 or click here to email

Donna V. Pledge, Barrister & Solicitor

Donna V Pledge, is a highly experienced criminal lawyer in Toronto with over twenty-five years of experience in the area of criminal offences. She has been successfully defending clients since 1992. She has earned the reputation of a tough and no-nonsense lawyer who can get her clients out of any criminal case with either a full acquittal or a very light sentence. Donna Pledge represents her clients in courts all over Ontario.